ReleaseStatus Minutes 2008-09-01 IRC log

(14:56:31) UweL [n=chatzill@nat/sun/x-45b61a1cf744aff9] hat den Raum betreten.
(14:58:33) bettina-h [n=Bettina_@nat/sun/x-be6477a9262ea4fa] hat den Raum betreten.
(15:00:12) kai_a [n=Kai_Ahre@nat/sun/x-fa53131f3b520ebf] hat den Raum betreten.
(15:00:17) _Nesshof_: moin
(15:00:25) ja_: hi
(15:00:46) ericb2: hello everybody
(15:00:46) MechtiIde: moin moin
(15:00:57) paveljanik: Moin
(15:00:59) jj: Hi
(15:01:12) bettina-h: hi
(15:01:21) rbircher [n=raphaelb@89-103.2-85.cust.bluewin.ch] hat den Raum betreten.
(15:01:36) rbircher: Hi all
(15:01:48) ja_: Hi Raphael
(15:01:49) _Nesshof_: it seems that the latest m4 snapshot was not a very good one :-(
(15:02:31) rbircher: _Nesshof_, Not realy
(15:02:43) _Nesshof_: but it looks that all issues blocking 88888 are right now fixed
(15:03:26) _Nesshof_: MechtiIde: have you reviewed the file tyoe regist spec ?
(15:03:37) paveljanik: _Nesshof_: yeah, but that Mac issue was also fixed resulting in a unusable Mac build 8)
(15:03:38) UweL: issue 92874 ?
(15:03:48) IZBot: Installation DEFECT NEW P3 Installer not add OpenOffice into applications menu http://qa.openoffice.org/issues/show_bug.cgi?id=92874
(15:04:01) MechtiIde: not till now, _Nesshof_
(15:04:11) ericb2: paveljanik: excepted that, the rest is very promising on Mac
(15:05:12) MechtiIde: what hppens with Issue 92239
(15:05:15) _Nesshof_: rtimm: jj, is ihi still working on issue 92874 ?
(15:05:20) IZBot: Presentation DEFECT RESOLVED FIXED P2 Office hangs or crashes when opening certain .pptx file http://qa.openoffice.org/issues/show_bug.cgi?id=92239
(15:05:27) IZBot: Installation DEFECT NEW P3 Installer not add OpenOffice into applications menu http://qa.openoffice.org/issues/show_bug.cgi?id=92874
(15:05:38) MechtiIde: this was a crash (P29 and fixed for 3.1 but not for 3.0
(15:06:43) jj: yes, IHI is still working on 92874
(15:06:45) _Nesshof_: MechtiIde: is there anything special in that file
(15:06:55) of_sun [n=chatzill@nat/sun/x-127a002334056ae1] hat den Raum betreten.
(15:07:41) MechtiIde: _Nesshof_, I dont know I found it in the automatic tests and stefan__b report it wich the result of your analysw
(15:08:32) MechtiIde: In the automatic tests I get eight crashes
(15:08:46) MechtiIde: at this place
(15:09:15) UweL: we discussed issue 92239 already and everybody agreed, why do we need to discuss it again?
(15:09:21) IZBot: Presentation DEFECT RESOLVED FIXED P2 Office hangs or crashes when opening certain .pptx file http://qa.openoffice.org/issues/show_bug.cgi?id=92239
(15:09:49) UweL: please read the issue
(15:10:08) MechtiIde: UweL, it is fixed for 3.1 and not for 3.0
(15:10:26) UweL: you agreed already
(15:12:08) rbircher: Maybe a backport should be good
(15:12:18) MechtiIde: And I don't know if you want to release a version with know crashes which can give data lost
(15:12:51) UweL: we discussed in the issue
(15:13:36) _Nesshof_: MechtiIde: it's during import right ? so I think, data loss is hyphthetical
(15:14:00) MechtiIde: _Nesshof_, data lost in the other files, they are open
(15:14:01) rtimm: _Nesshof_: yes, he is. That issue is only partly fixed up to now.
(15:14:55) _Nesshof_: rtimm: has ihi a realistic due date for the cws (sysui30)?
(15:15:50) _Nesshof_: of_sun: is Sept 5 as due date meant serious for native190/191 ?
(15:15:51) rtimm: _Nesshof_: seems to be constant - 'today'
(15:16:59) MechtiIde: _Nesshof_, that means if I open a new document I have to save/close all other files because of a high risk to lost data
(15:17:03) rtimm: 'hope to have it finished by today evening. But not sure, already hoped that last friday'
(15:17:44) MechtiIde: then we must publish this information
(15:17:46) _Nesshof_: MechtiIde: but this is true for any crash issue
(15:18:01) _Nesshof_: MechtiIde: which information ?
(15:18:08) MechtiIde: only it happens on opening
(15:18:31) MechtiIde: in other situations the recovery works mostly very good
(15:18:34) of_sun: _Nesshoff_: Hopefully not. What due date is valueable?
(15:18:41) volkerme: _Nesshof_: We wanted to hold up a sign with "We can import MS-XML"
(15:19:10) volkerme: With a little footnote "some of them" :-(
(15:19:51) _Nesshof_: volkerme: MechtiIde: but we also know that the msxml import can't be so good like ms-binary at the moment
(15:20:26) _Nesshof_: volkerme: I'm afraid if we begin to fix any import issue, this will get an endless story
(15:20:42) MechtiIde: I have nor problem with import issues
(15:20:53) _Nesshof_: but that's why I asked for the root cause of the crash
(15:21:02) volkerme: I would accept things like wrong formatting, but not a crash
(15:21:05) MechtiIde: I have problems with crashes at opening a document
(15:21:22) volkerme: At my system there came no recovery, nothing
(15:21:49) _Nesshof_: MechtiIde: volkerme, I will check if a backport will be possbile
(15:21:59) volkerme: So let's give ihi another cup of coffee to fix it until tomorrow morning
(15:22:35) _Nesshof_: of_sun: I would like to do a rc this week
(15:24:29) rtimm: volkerme: ihi only works on system integration, not the crash on import
(15:25:33) of_sun: I can't contact Ingo. I think (hope) that these CWSs are ready tomorrow so that at least one of the will be approved on wednesday. The other should be ok at least on thurstday.
(15:26:41) rbircher: _Nesshof_, Thanks
(15:28:07) _Nesshof_: daniel will bakport 92239
(15:28:49) _Nesshof_: stefan__b: will prob. be done in dba30j
(15:29:23) UweL: stefan_b is gone
(15:29:32) _Nesshof_: anything else regarding 3.0 issues ?
(15:29:34) rbircher: issue 93248
(15:29:39) IZBot: gsl DEFECT RESOLVED DUPLICATE P3 Aqua: gravis accent misbehaves in MultiLineEdits http://qa.openoffice.org/issues/show_bug.cgi?id=93248
(15:30:00) rbircher: and issue 93155
(15:30:06) IZBot: gsl PATCH RESOLVED FIXED P3 Aqua: problem in text input of single ASCII character using input method http://qa.openoffice.org/issues/show_bug.cgi?id=93155
(15:30:27) mod [n=mod@dslb-084-063-246-238.pools.arcor-ip.net] hat den Raum betreten.
(15:30:41) rbircher: are realy showstoppers?
(15:31:22) _Nesshof_: rbircher: also in dba30j
(15:31:32) _Nesshof_: I also wondered for a second
(15:32:01) _Nesshof_: I would not accept if the fix would have been in platform independent code
(15:32:22) _Nesshof_: and I also think that such character I quite common for some locales
(15:34:40) _Nesshof_: rtimm: RE duties this week ?
(15:35:08) rtimm: I'll finish DEV300 m31. Probably no m32 this week?
(15:35:17) rtimm: Oliver (obo) will do OOO300 m5
(15:35:31) ja_: I'll do uploads
(15:36:12) _Nesshof_: ok, anything else for today ?
(15:36:23) MechtiIde: Can there be an update of Release Date?
(15:37:06) _Nesshof_: MechtiIde: as I said earlier: I would like to do this week, but of_sun will check regarding the due dates
(15:37:52) _Nesshof_: so September is still possible (but may be not realistic ?)
(15:38:11) MechtiIde: we need it for planning some publications
(15:39:08) of_sun: _Nesshof_:Corrections: native190 will be ready for QA today. Probably approved tomorrow. native191 probably approved wednesday.
(15:39:11) _Nesshof_: i'm quite optimistic by saying: we will release second half of september :-)
(15:39:26) _Nesshof_: of_sun: ok, fine
(15:40:13) _Nesshof_: ok, by
(15:41:16) mdamboldt hat den Raum verlassen
(15:41:27) UweL hat den Raum verlassen (quit: "ChatZilla 0.9.83 [Firefox 3.0/2008052906]").
(15:41:34) rtimm: bye
(15:42:04) rbircher: Bye
(15:42:10) rtimm hat den Raum verlassen
(15:42:11) mod hat den Raum verlassen
(15:42:27) ja_: bye